
‘A steampunk Mr Tayto’: why Irish critics hate Netflix’s House of Guinness
While US and UK reviewers have praised the series, in Ireland it has faced a barrage of withering put-downs
Netflix's "House of Guinness" Sparks Debate on Irish Authenticity Dublin, Ireland – The upcoming Netflix series "House of Guinness" has ignited discussions among viewers and cultural commentators regarding its portrayal of Irish history and identity. Social media personality Garron Noone, known for his commentary on Irish culture, recently reviewed the series, emphasizing the importance of authentic representation. Noone, who playfully refers to himself as the "Irish cultural police," expressed his satisfaction with the casting, noting that "most of the cast are Irish, so we have actual Irish accents." This detail has been a point of contention for many viewers of historical dramas set in Ireland, who often criticize non-Irish actors attempting the accent. The series, which delves into the historical context of the iconic Guinness family, also features scenes that touch upon Anglo-Irish relations. Noone highlighted a moment where the cry "Free Ireland from the English!" is heard, suggesting the show will address significant historical tensions. This inclusion indicates a commitment to historical accuracy and cultural relevance, potentially appealing to a broad audience interested in Irish heritage and history.
While US and UK reviewers have praised the series, in Ireland it has faced a barrage of withering put-downs