US Repeats 1955 Mistake: Visa Revokes for Chinese Students Spark Debate

The United States is once again facing criticism for its handling of Chinese talent. In 1955, the US deported renowned physicist Chen Xue-sheng, a decision later described as "the stupidest thing the US ever did." Now, in 2025, Secretary of State Marco Rubio has announced plans to revoke visas for thousands of Chinese students, many in STEM fields. This action raises concerns about the impact on American innovation and research. "That one decision from the US, driven by fear and racism, changed the entire global power balance," explains one commentator, referencing the 1955 incident. This new policy could lead to a loss of billions in tuition revenue and a significant setback in research and development. The parallel with the past raises questions about whether the US is repeating a costly mistake, potentially benefiting China's own technological advancement. Experts are divided, with some arguing that national security concerns necessitate such measures, while others warn of the long-term economic and scientific consequences.