Broadway Stars' Favorite Musicals: A Surprising Mix of Classics and Modern Hits

Broadway Stars Reveal Their Top Three Favorite Musicals New York, NY – June 16, 2025 – In a recent Playbill video, Broadway stars Jeremy Jordan, Lizzy McAlpine, and Jason Gotay shared their personal favorite musicals. The video, which has already garnered significant views and engagement, offers a unique perspective on the enduring appeal of Broadway. Jordan, known for his role in "Newsies," chose "West Side Story" as his number one pick, citing the iconic nature of the show and a dream role he fulfilled. He stated, "It's like a dream role of mine to play Tony, which I got to do." McAlpine selected "Falsettos," praising its intricate score, and later added "Next to Normal" to her list. Gotay, known for his work in "Hamilton," chose "Les Miserables." The video also features McAlpine's appreciation for "Parade," highlighting its revival and her admiration for composer Jason Robert Brown. The video concludes with Jordan selecting "Little Shop of Horrors" as his third favorite, calling it a "quintessentially crafted show." The video's popularity underscores the continued interest in Broadway and the power of celebrity endorsements in shaping cultural trends. The diverse selections of the stars offer a glimpse into the varied tastes within the Broadway community, highlighting the rich and diverse history of musical theatre.