New Historical Analysis Challenges Traditional View of Russian Principalities and the Golden Horde

Were the Russian Principalities Part of the Golden Horde's Ulus? A Historical Analysis The question of the relationship between the Russian principalities and the Golden Horde during the 13th century continues to be debated by historians. A recent short video by the YouTube channel Politsovetnik ЮВ presents a concise argument that the principalities were vassals of the Golden Horde, paying tribute but not being fully integrated into its ulus (territory). The video, which uses historical maps to illustrate its points, contends that the Golden Horde's ulus was geographically distinct from the Russian principalities. The author, Politsovetnik2.0, states, "Russian principalities were vassally subordinate and paid tribute; they acknowledged the supremacy of the Golden Horde Khan." This assertion challenges the traditional view that the Russian principalities were directly incorporated into the Golden Horde's administrative structure. The video's argument is based on the geographical location of the Golden Horde's capital, Sarai Batu, and the nature of the tribute paid by the Russian principalities. By highlighting the geographical separation and the nature of the tributary relationship, the author provides a compelling argument for a more nuanced understanding of this historical period. While the video provides a succinct overview, further research is needed to fully explore the complexities of this historical interaction. However, the video serves as a valuable starting point for a broader discussion on the topic, prompting further investigation into the political and economic dynamics of the time.