American Idol's Secret: Why Luke Combs Wasn't Chosen as Judge

American Idol's Judge Surprise: Why Luke Combs Wasn't Chosen American Idol viewers may be surprised to learn that Carrie Underwood wasn't the show's first choice for judge. Sources close to the production reveal that country music star Luke Combs was the top contender to replace Katy Perry. "The network would kill for Luke Combs. He's at the top of their list," an insider stated. However, a logistical hurdle prevented Combs from joining the panel. The current lineup already includes three male judges, creating an imbalance that the show's producers were unwilling to risk. "He really is the perfect package for this show, but the panel cannot be three men, so it wouldn't work out with this current lineup," the insider added. This news adds another layer to the ongoing speculation surrounding Underwood's future on American Idol, as previous reports suggested she wasn't the network's initial pick. While Combs' absence is a missed opportunity, the show's unique dynamic remains intact.