Should Original Creators Be Involved in Adaptations? A Look at Lilo & Stitch and Super Mario Bros.

In the dynamic world of film adaptations, the question of involving original creators remains a critical point of discussion. Recent live-action remakes have sparked heated debate, and one insightful video essay by TheYonkoTable highlights this issue. Using Disney's Lilo & Stitch and the Super Mario Bros. movie as key examples, the author argues that excluding original creators can lead to significant creative shortcomings. "They missed the mark on a lot of shit in this movie," TheYonkoTable states, highlighting a common sentiment among fans of the original works. The essay further points to the Super Mario Bros. movie's disastrous reception and Nintendo's subsequent reluctance to license its IP. While acknowledging exceptions, the author emphasizes the potential benefits of collaboration with original creators for a more authentic and successful adaptation. This approach, the video suggests, could lead to a richer, more satisfying experience for audiences and a more respectful approach to beloved franchises.